Pros: Good location (well, close to Times Square, Broadway, MSG etc but not my favourite part of Manhattan), ok value for money, hot and cold breakfast (be sure to be there before 9 though, after that things run out). Room was ok size with fridge, safe, ironing equipment. Not too much street noise for mid town.
Cons: Not the cleanest room, stains on the quilts etc, safe didn't work, under dimensioned breakfast area, long wait for elevator during breakfast, the key cards stopped working basically once per day, thin doors with potential nightly noise from hallway.